"The evidence is: Novum 1 photo of the late Rizky Rudiana at Gunung Jati Hospital Cirebon," said Saka Tatal's attorney in the courtroom, as reported by merdeka.com. The photo was taken on August 20, 2016, specifically after Eky was taken from the Flyover to Gunung Jati Hospital by the police. In that photo and based on the autopsy, there are no wounds from sharp weapons or samurai on Eky's body."

"There is no connection between the single punch with bare hands delivered by Saka Tatal to the victim's child at the scene, secondly in the showroom on Jalan Perjuangan Cirebon," he said. Novum two, a photo of the victim Vina at RS Gunung Jati on August 20 at 23:30 WIB. The Saka Tatal party explained that the photo of Vina contradicts the judge's considerations which state that Brother Andi swung a samurai sword towards Vina's face and legs."

"So there is no causal relationship between Saka Tatal's actions and Vina's death," he said. The third novum, a photo of Vina at Gunung Jati Hospital showing bleeding from both nostrils. The fourth novum. Fragments of the victim's flesh on the shoulder road support bolt."

"The fifth novum is the photo of the victim's motorcycle, Muhammad Rizky Rudiana, obtained on August 29, 2016. It shows the victim's blue Yamaha Xeon motorcycle. The cover has been damaged due to friction with the road surface. This is in accordance with the statement of two police officers," explained the legal advisor. The sixth novum is a file in a flash drive containing a statement from Liga Akbar, who claims to have been ordered by Rudiana. Liga Akbar was also not at the scene when the incident occurred."

Novum eighth, the recording file in the flash drive contains a statement from Dedi Mulyadi that the local neighborhood children were hanging out with the convicts but did not participate in the investigation. In this case, out of 8 convicts, only Saka Tatal has been released after serving his sentence. The other seven convicts are still languishing in prison.