Due to the accident, Grabska was unable to work for more than five years. He also added that the accident made him unable to carry his children, complete basic tasks, or lift heavy bags. Sometimes he also needs pain relievers every time he wants to go to sleep.

However, all of these claims were refuted when the judge of the High Court of Ireland in Limerick received evidence in the form of a photo. In the photo, Grabska can be seen throwing a Christmas tree in January 2018, just a year after the accident she experienced. In the photo, Grabska, who is a resident of Ennis, is among several people throwing a 1.5-meter tall fir tree in the said competition.

The local Irish page reported that Grabska admitted to Judge Carmel Stewart that she won the competition. Another evidence also comes from a 2018 article from the outlet that mentioned Grabska as the winner of the women's competition. Grabska is featured in the main image wearing a yellow jacket and work gloves, and appears to be throwing a tree.

"I am concerned that I cannot conclude that the claim is completely exaggerated," said the judge. The court also showed footage of Grabska playing with a Dalmatian dog in the park for about 90 minutes, according to The Irish Independent. The recording was taken in November 2023, The Telegraph reported.