Better experience in portrait mode.
Berikan Dissenting Opinion, Hakim MK Saldi Isra Nilai Politisasi Bansos Terjadi di Pilpres 2024

"Give Dissenting Opinion, MK Judge Saldi Isra Evaluates Politicization of Social Assistance Occurring in the 2024 Presidential Election"

Dream - Constitutional Justice Hakim Saldi Isra believes that the allegation of the existence of politicians involved in the Social Assistance (bansos) is one of the arguments presented by the applicants Anies-Muhaimin, and it is proven to have occurred in the 2024 Presidential Election (Pilpres). Saldi conveyed this statement while reading his dissenting opinion during the hearing of the verdict on the dispute over the 2024 Presidential Election, which rejected all requests from Presidential Candidates number 01 and 03. "Based on these legal considerations and facts, the distribution of bansos or any other name for electoral purposes cannot be completely denied," said Saldi Isra in the Constitutional Court room, Jakarta, on Monday, April 22, 2024.

Give Dissenting Opinion, Judge MK Saldi Isra Values Politicization of Social Assistance Occurring in the 2024 Presidential Election

As a moral obligation, Saldi conveyed, he reminded that the Constitutional Court (MK) needs to make a decision to anticipate and prevent the recurrence of similar circumstances in every General Election contestation (Pemilu).

Saldi reminded that in a few months, Indonesia will hold simultaneous regional head and deputy regional head elections nationwide. "The use of state/regional budgets by incumbents, state officials, or by regional heads in order to win one of the supported election participants can be exploited as a legal loophole and can be imitated as part of the election strategy," he said.

The Vice Chairman of the Constitutional Court believes that, with the acceptance of the evidence, it will prevent similar incidents in the upcoming regional head elections to be held in November 2024. "By declaring the aforementioned evidence proven, it will send a clear message and have a deterrent effect on all candidates in the upcoming November 2024 regional head and deputy regional head elections to not engage in similar actions," he said.

"Thus, I am convinced that the Applicant's argument regarding the politicization of social assistance is legally justified,"
say Saldi Isra.

"Dream.co.id."

In that occasion, Saldi also strengthened his opinion by referring back to the statement of the Minister of Social Affairs, Tri Rismaharini, during the hearing. At that time, Tri Risma stated that she was not directly involved in the distribution of social assistance in the field, which was mentioned by the legal team of Presidential Candidate 01.

Give Dissenting Opinion, Judge MK Saldi Isra Values Politicization of Social Assistance Occurring in the 2024 Presidential Election

"The facts revealed during the trial process, the minister directly involved in the task, in this case, the Minister of Social Affairs who should have been responsible for the distribution of social assistance, stated that he has never been involved and/or involved directly in the distribution or delivery of social assistance in the field,"

ungkap Saldi.

               
Give Dissenting Opinion, Judge MK Saldi Isra Values Politicization of Social Assistance Occurring in the 2024 Presidential Election

He mentioned, it was also revealed in the trial that a number of active ministers directly provided social assistance to the community during the campaign period.

"Furthermore, it was also revealed during the trial that there were several active ministers who distributed social assistance to the community, especially during the campaign period."
"tuturnya." translates to "he/she said."

"Dream.co.id."

50 Words of Encouragement for Long Distance Relationship Partners that Motivate, Cure Longing, and Make the Relationship More Harmonious

50 Words of Encouragement for Long Distance Relationship Partners that Motivate, Cure Longing, and Make the Relationship More Harmonious

Words not only provide encouragement to partners who are far apart, but also express longing.

Read More icon-hand
MK Judge Arief Hidayat: The Assumption that the President Can Campaign Cannot be Accepted by Reason

MK Judge Arief Hidayat: The Assumption that the President Can Campaign Cannot be Accepted by Reason

MK Judge Arief Hidayat: The Assumption that the President Can Campaign Cannot be Accepted by Reason

Read More icon-hand
MK Rejects Anies and Ganjar's Lawsuit, Here's Gibran's Reaction

MK Rejects Anies and Ganjar's Lawsuit, Here's Gibran's Reaction

The Mayor of Solo does not deny that there will be pro and contra attitudes from supporters after the Constitutional Court's decision.

Read More icon-hand
Anies-Cak Imin's Expression When the Constitutional Court Rejects All Disputes Over the 2024 Presidential Election, No Smile

Anies-Cak Imin's Expression When the Constitutional Court Rejects All Disputes Over the 2024 Presidential Election, No Smile

Without a smile, Anies-Cak Imin's expression hears the Constitutional Court's decision to reject the disputes over the 2024 Presidential Election.

Read More icon-hand
50 Words of Motivation for Hard Work, a Source of Inspiration for the Importance of Determination in Achieving Success

50 Words of Motivation for Hard Work, a Source of Inspiration for the Importance of Determination in Achieving Success

The following words of motivation for hard work can be a priceless source of inspiration.

Read More icon-hand
Constitutional Court Rejects Lawsuit on 2024 Presidential Election Dispute by Ganjar-Mahfud

Constitutional Court Rejects Lawsuit on 2024 Presidential Election Dispute by Ganjar-Mahfud

This is the second request that the Constitutional Court has rejected regarding the dispute over the results of the 2024 Presidential Election. The first request, filed by Anies-Cak Imin, was also rejected.

Read More icon-hand
Saldi Isra: The Constitutional Court Should Order a Revote in Several Regions

Saldi Isra: The Constitutional Court Should Order a Revote in Several Regions

Saldi Isra: The Constitutional Court Should Order a Revote in Several Regions

Read More icon-hand
Feeling Anxious? Here's a Prayer for Sadness that Can be a Soothing Remedy for the Heart

Feeling Anxious? Here's a Prayer for Sadness that Can be a Soothing Remedy for the Heart

Prayer is not only to seek guidance from Allah SWT but also capable of making oneself calmer.

Read More icon-hand
Constitutional Court Says Jokowi's Endorsement of Prabowo-Gibran Doesn't Violate the Law, but Could Potentially Become an Ethical Issue

Constitutional Court Says Jokowi's Endorsement of Prabowo-Gibran Doesn't Violate the Law, but Could Potentially Become an Ethical Issue

The Constitutional Court judges that President Jokowi's endorsement of Candidate Pair 02 does not violate the law.

Read More icon-hand
Ganjar Pranowo's Restless Expression Recorded by Camera During MK's Verdict Finding No Evidence of Jokowi's Intervention in Gibran's Candidacy

Ganjar Pranowo's Restless Expression Recorded by Camera During MK's Verdict Finding No Evidence of Jokowi's Intervention in Gibran's Candidacy

Ganjar was caught on camera showing a restless expression.

Read More icon-hand
Constitutional Court Rejects All Lawsuits of Presidential Election Dispute 2024 by Anies-Cak Imin

Constitutional Court Rejects All Lawsuits of Presidential Election Dispute 2024 by Anies-Cak Imin

The Constitutional Court initially declared its authority to adjudicate Anies-Cak Imin's petition. The Constitutional Court then read out considerations regarding various arguments.

Read More icon-hand
What if Fasting Syawal is Not Completed for 6 Days? Here's an Important Explanation for Muslims to Know

What if Fasting Syawal is Not Completed for 6 Days? Here's an Important Explanation for Muslims to Know

Fasting for six days in Syawal can earn the reward of fasting for a whole year.

Read More icon-hand
Constitutional Court Rejects AMIN's Argument on Jokowi's Election Meddling: No Strong Evidence Found

Constitutional Court Rejects AMIN's Argument on Jokowi's Election Meddling: No Strong Evidence Found

The Constitutional Court did not find strong evidence of President Jokowi meddling in the 2024 Election.

Read More icon-hand
Constitutional Court Does Not Find Correlation between Distribution of Social Assistance and Increase in Prabowo-Gibran's Voice

Constitutional Court Does Not Find Correlation between Distribution of Social Assistance and Increase in Prabowo-Gibran's Voice

Constitutional Judge Arsul Sani assesses that there is no anomaly in the social assistance budget ahead of the 2024 Presidential Election.

Read More icon-hand
MK Nilai Putusan MKMK Tak Bisa Jadi Bukti Nepotisme-Abuse of Power Jokowi

MK Nilai Putusan MKMK Tak Bisa Jadi Bukti Nepotisme-Abuse of Power Jokowi

Arief stated that the Constitutional Court cannot question the requirements for Gibran Rakabuming Raka's candidacy.

Read More icon-hand
Hakim Saldi Isra: MK is not a 'Trash Can' to Solve All Election Problems

Hakim Saldi Isra: MK is not a 'Trash Can' to Solve All Election Problems

The judge says the Constitutional Court is not a 'trash can' to solve all problems in the series of elections.

Read More icon-hand
Constitutional Court Rejects Anies-Muhaimin's Lawsuit Claim, Deems Gibran's Nomination Valid, No Evidence of Jokowi's Intervention

Constitutional Court Rejects Anies-Muhaimin's Lawsuit Claim, Deems Gibran's Nomination Valid, No Evidence of Jokowi's Intervention

This was conveyed by Constitutional Court Judge Arief Hidayat during the reading of the verdict on the 2024 Presidential Election case at the Constitutional Court Building on Monday, April 22, 2024.

Read More icon-hand
Issue Arises of Jokowi Calling Judge Prior to Presidential Election Lawsuit Verdict, Here's What the Constitutional Court Says

Issue Arises of Jokowi Calling Judge Prior to Presidential Election Lawsuit Verdict, Here's What the Constitutional Court Says

Constitutional Court's response to the issue of Jokowi calling the judge before the reading of the Presidential Election lawsuit verdict in 2024.

Read More icon-hand